Referee's notebook

Kings in the Corner Disputed Moves: A Referee's Notebook

House rules can produce a different ruling. At this table, the card below settles the argument.

Case 01. Black 9 on Black 10

Cards on the table: the ten of spades, exposed

Card played: the nine of clubs

Claim: The ranks descend correctly, so the move should stand.

On the table
Played

The proposed move is the nine of clubs onto the exposed ten of spades.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal The 9 is one rank below the 10, but both cards are black. A red 9 is required. Either the nine of hearts or the nine of diamonds would be legal.

Case 02. Red 9 on Black 10

Cards on the table: the ten of clubs, exposed

Card played: the nine of hearts

Claim: Hearts and clubs are different suits, so the move is legal.

On the table
Played

The proposed move is the nine of hearts onto the exposed ten of clubs.

Legal

Ruling: Legal The suits happen to differ, but colour is what matters. The black 10 takes a red 9. The same move would be legal with the nine of diamonds.

Case 03. Queen in an Empty Corner

Position: The north-east diagonal corner is empty.

Card played: the queen of spades

Claim: The space is empty, so any high card can begin it.

CornerNorth-east corner, empty
Played

The proposed move is the queen of spades into the empty north-east corner.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal Only a King may start one of the four diagonal corner piles. The Queen needs an opposite-coloured King, or an empty original north, east, south or west position.

Case 04. King in an Empty Original Position

Position: The west original pile has been moved away, leaving west empty.

Card played from the hand: the king of diamonds

Claim: Kings belong only in corners.

PositionWest original, empty
Played

The proposed move is the king of diamonds into the empty west original position.

Legal

Ruling: Legal, but usually wasteful The King-only restriction applies to starting diagonal corner piles. Any card from the hand may begin an empty original position under this table's rules, so the king of diamonds may be played west. An open corner is normally the better destination because it is reserved for Kings; the original space can then release another blocked card.

Case 05. Opening King Moved to a Corner

Opening layout: the king of hearts, dealt face up in the north original position

Move: The first player moves it to the empty north-west corner.

Claim: A King already on the table cannot be moved, because cards may be played only from the hand.

North
CornerNorth-west corner, empty

The proposed move is the king of hearts from the north original position to the empty north-west corner.

Legal

Ruling: Legal as an opening treatment An opening King in one of the four original positions may be moved to a diagonal corner. North becomes empty and can be filled from the first player's hand. Agree this before the deal, because some groups handle opening Kings before the first turn.

Case 06. Moving a Pile by Its Exposed Card

Moving pile: the queen of clubs as the base, the jack of diamonds, then the ten of clubs exposed

Destination pile: the jack of hearts, exposed

Claim: The black 10 fits on the red Jack, so the pile can move.

Moving pile
Destination

The base is the leftmost card. It decides where the pile may go.

The proposed move is the whole queen of clubs pile onto the exposed jack of hearts.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal The exposed 10 would fit if it were a loose card in the hand, or a complete single-card pile. It is neither. The moving pile is judged by the queen of clubs at its base, and a black Queen needs a red King.

Case 07. The Base Card Fits

Moving pile: the eight of diamonds as the base, the seven of clubs, then the six of hearts exposed

Destination pile: the nine of spades, exposed

Claim: The exposed 6 does not fit on the 9, so the move is illegal.

Moving pile
Destination

The proposed move is the whole eight of diamonds pile onto the exposed nine of spades.

Legal

Ruling: Legal The red 8 base is one rank below the black 9. The complete pile of 8, 7 and 6 moves as one unit, and the exposed 6 stays exposed after the move.

Case 08. Taking the Bottom Half of a Pile

Pile: the king of clubs as the base, the queen of hearts, the jack of clubs, the ten of diamonds, then the nine of spades exposed

Proposed move: Lift the ten of diamonds and the nine of spades together and place them on the jack of spades.

Claim: The red 10 fits on the black Jack and the two lifted cards remain in order.

Pile
Destination

The proposed lift takes only the last two cards, which is not a complete pile.

The proposed move lifts the ten of diamonds and nine of spades out of a five-card pile and places them on the jack of spades.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal A pile may not be split. The whole King-based pile would have to move, and no card can receive its King base.

Case 09. Peeling Off the Exposed Card

Pile: the seven of clubs as the base, the six of hearts, then the five of spades exposed

Proposed move: Move only the five of spades onto the six of diamonds.

Claim: A single card is being moved, so the pile rule does not apply.

Pile
Destination

The proposed move takes the five of spades off the top of a three-card pile and places it on the six of diamonds.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal The 5 is part of a multi-card layout pile and cannot be peeled away. A single-card pile may move, because that one card is the complete pile. A single card taken from a longer pile is not.

Case 10. A Complete Pile Moved Into an Empty Original Position

Position: East is empty.

Moving pile: the jack of clubs, the ten of diamonds, then the nine of clubs

Claim: The sequence is complete and the empty east position accepts any card.

PositionEast original, empty
Moving pile

The proposed move puts a complete three-card pile into the empty east original position.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal under this table's version East is filled by one card from the hand. A complete layout pile cannot move into the empty position merely because the space is open. Some house rules allow a card or a sequence to fill an empty original position; that is not the rule on this table's card.

Case 11. An Ace Begins an Empty Original Position

Position: South is empty after its pile moves.

Card played from the hand: the ace of clubs

Claim: An Ace cannot start a pile because nothing can follow it.

PositionSouth original, empty
Played

The proposed move is the ace of clubs into the empty south original position.

Legal

Ruling: Legal Any card from the hand may begin an empty original position. The Ace ends the pile immediately, but that does not make the play illegal.

Case 12. A Card Played Beneath an Ace

Pile ends with: the ace of diamonds

Card played: the king of clubs

Claim: The rank order wraps from Ace back to King.

Pile ends with
Played

The proposed move is the king of clubs beneath the ace of diamonds at the foot of a pile.

Illegal

Ruling: Illegal Ace is low and closes the pile. Nothing can be built beneath it, and the rank order does not wrap from Ace back to King.

Case 19. A Player Empties the Hand After Drawing

Position: The player begins the turn holding one card, draws another and legally plays both.

Claim: The player must wait until the next turn, because the hand contained a drawn card.

Held
Drawn
After the turnHand empty

The player holds one card, draws a second and plays both in the same turn.

Legal

Ruling: The player wins immediately The required draw has already been taken. Once every card in the hand has been played, the round ends.

Case 20. Two Opening Cards Already Fit

Opening layout: north the eight of hearts, east the nine of clubs, south the four of diamonds, west the queen of spades

Move: The first player moves the single eight of hearts pile onto the nine of clubs.

Claim: The opening cards must stay in their original positions until every player has taken a turn.

Opening
After the moveNorth original, empty

North, east, south and west, in that order.

The proposed move takes the single-card north pile, the eight of hearts, onto the east pile headed by the nine of clubs.

Legal

Ruling: Legal The red 8 is one rank below the black 9. A single-card pile is still a complete pile, so it may move. North becomes empty and the first player may fill it with a card from the hand.